arisha: (potc3 liz boat)
arisha ([personal profile] arisha) wrote2010-02-26 05:28 am
Entry tags:

headlines

~ I am getting really sick of being told, by co-workers and by bloggers, that if I don't care about the Olympics, I obviously don't care about my country. Please. I am not interested in the Olympics because I am not interested in sports. Don't waste your time trying to turn it into anything more than that.

~ You've probably all heard of the trainer who was killed at SeaWorld Orlando on Wednesday due to an incident with one of the orcas there. I've had a variety of different reactions to this; the one reaction I have not had is surprise. Maybe I shouldn't even be talking about this, because I know I'm a total hypocrite on the subject of zoos and aquariums - I frequently visit them at the same time as I condemn them. And I guess I only really speak out against them when the specific animal in question is a marine mammal, because I am a hypocrite who plays favourites. But seriously, orcas and captivity just don't work. This is far from the first time that a captive orca has caused harm to a human (although I admit I was surprised to see that Wikipedia gives this subject its own page); captive orcas have also been reported to have injured themselves, for example by smashing their heads against the walls of their tanks. I find the arguments against keeping whales in captivity a million times more compelling than any of the arguments for it, especially if we're going to continue to use them as entertainers.

I have no idea how to write about this, so I'll link you to a blog post entitled A Few Thoughts on Tilikum which brings up a lot of the points I've been thinking about. It also briefly discusses Tilikum's history, which is not at all a happy one.

One thing that I'm really not impressed with is the number of people who are calling for Tilikum to be killed. This incident may have been an accident or it may have been intentional, but either way, it seems absurd to me to fault a wild animal for reminding us that he's a wild animal.

[identity profile] frauleinfrog.livejournal.com 2010-03-01 11:54 pm (UTC)(link)
...what. Maybe this is just the voice of somebody raised on Free Willy, but, uh... why don't you let him go?

long comment is long

[identity profile] arisha.livejournal.com 2010-03-02 12:08 am (UTC)(link)
There are issues with simply letting him go - wild orcas live in pods and he wouldn't really have a pod to go back to, he's been in captivity so long he might not remember how to live in the wild, etc. Keiko was released back into the wild but that was only after, iirc, a long rehabilitation program. I did see people suggesting that Tilikum be put into an ocean pen (near Iceland? I guess they have some up there or something? or maybe these commenters were just making stuff up), so that he would at least be not quite as captive as he is now and he'd no longer be forced to entertain, but I guess the bottom line is that he still makes money for SeaWorld so they don't want to let him go. :| They've already resumed the orca shows (http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20100227/us_nm/us_usa_whale_2) (although Tilikum isn't a part of them right now) and people are still attending them, so ...

In related news, Matt Damon wants SeaWorld shut down (http://www.3news.co.nz/Matt-Damon-wants-SeaWorld-shut-down-after-trainers-death/tabid/418/articleID/144026/Default.aspx?ArticleID=144026) completely, wow!

Not TOO long, though.

[identity profile] frauleinfrog.livejournal.com 2010-03-02 12:16 am (UTC)(link)
Yeah, that's true. It would be kind of lonely for him to live all by himself. But rehabilitation? Why not? Better than either of the other two options, if you ask me. (Which the world totally did. Also, finally, someone to ask- iirc stands for?)

As;elkfj, money. Did I tell you about the whale that appeared in our school lunch here? At least the US isn't whaling under the guise of science. >.>

Rock on, Matt Damon! :D

Re: Not TOO long, though.

[identity profile] arisha.livejournal.com 2010-03-02 12:28 am (UTC)(link)
iirc = if I recall/remember correctly x)

And if you told me about the whale in your school lunch, I must have blocked it out of my memory. o_O Did they feed you guys whale??

!

[identity profile] frauleinfrog.livejournal.com 2010-03-02 03:49 am (UTC)(link)
Mysteries solved~! Thank you! :D

I made a facebook status about it, surely you saw it. :p

Yeah, they totally did. I was extremely surprised, and also felt like a terrible person for eating it. But at the time that felt like a better decision than letting it be thrown away, which is what happens to waste food.